Ease of doing business

Please refer to my earlier post in this blog: http://obvioustruths.blogspot.in/2016/10/filing-complaint-with-police.html

I spent four hours and made two visits to a BSNL office and one visit to a police station; these were spread over two different days. This was all for getting a lost cell phone SIM replaced. Earlier, I had made a call to the BSNL call center to get the lost SIM barred. After my visit to the BSNL office, I 

• ·       filled in one form,
• ·       submitted a copy of my driver’s license,
• ·       registered with a police website as a user,
• ·       filled in a lost item complaint and
• ·       printed out a digitally signed copy of my complaint.

At the end, BSNL told me to pay Rs 20 for a new SIM and gave it to me. Obviously, some checking was necessary to make sure that I was not getting a new SIM for someone else’s phone number, but can the process be simplified? Banking and other financial services have made tremendous strides in making things easier for users. Can’t other sectors of the economy learn from them. I guess that it is not the job of a public-sector telecom company to worry about the customer’s time. Private sector telecom companies handle similar transactions a lot better – for instance one of them has equipped its outlets with photocopy machines to avoid telling the customer to run around for a getting a photocopy of his/her driving license.

So, we come to the question of whose business it is to worry about the citizen’s time and efficiency in getting things done. Who should worry about Rs 2000 worth of time being spent to get a Rs 20 worth of SIM?

India does not create even a million jobs a year,

http://www.thehindubusinessline.com/opinion/job-creation-is-unfinished-business/article9246290.ece

,while the population goes up by 15 million per year or more. http://www.worldometers.info/world-population/india-population/ 

Why? Part of the reason may be that the average Indian’s efficiency at work seems to be nobody’s business.

Ranking of economies - Doing Business - World Bank Group

Gives India the rank of 130 out of 189 countries in ease of doing business. The factors considered in calculating this rank is the ease of: Starting a business, dealing with construction permits, registering property, paying taxes, Trading across borders, enforcing contracts, and resolving insolvency.

The website goes further to rank seventeen cities of India on the ease of doing business as follows:

Hyderabad                       2

Ahmedabad                     5

New Delhi                       6

Mumbai                         10

Bengaluru                      13

Chennai                         15

Kolkata                          17

What can we do about this mess? I believe a lot can be done. If you are completing your education and live in a badly managed city/state, plan to move out! It is difficult to build a first-rate career in a third-rate environment.

If you are going to stay, use your vote in the next election to elect politicians likely to improve the working environment in your city/state. 
P. S. The queue in the photograph above has nothing to do with telecom or cell phones. It does, however, illustrate the fact that Indians are usually made to waste time in getting things done. 

Filing a complaint with the police

I lost a BSNL SIM in Bangalore on 18/10/2016 and went to their office asking for a replacement (For those of you who do not know it - Bharat Sanchar Nigam Ltd. is the Govt. owned telecom service provider in India). I was told to file a police complaint and then file an application. I went through the first part of this process and was rewarded with an eye-opening experience. The police station told me to visit the URL http://www.bcp.gov.in and file a complaint online. I went to this website and clicked on “Lost and Found” and was directed to this page:

http://218.248.45.3:1300/

I registered myself as a user, giving ID information, mobile number, address etc. I received a One-Time Password on my email address. Using this, I completed the registration and filled in my complaint. I got a digitally signed copy of the police record of my complaint, which I will submit to BSNL tomorrow. 

What is eye-opening about this?

We can now do this for a lost cell phone, a lost card like a driver’s license, etc. I believe that the courts can and should order this process to be made available to complain about serious crimes too. Visit the following page to read the legal provisions relating to the First Information Report (FIR).

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/First_Information_Report

In reality, filing an FIR requires cooperation by the police station concerned. This introduces a weakness in the system, sometimes allowing the powerful, the rich and others interfering in this first step in seeking redress.

There is logic in requiring that the identity of the complainant should be verified before a complaint is recorded. In this age of digitalization, this process can be automated at least for a significant part of the population. This part of the population, having access to the Internet and the necessary skills to file an online complaint, can also help others when necessary.

The Electronically Filed Complaint (EFC) need not be called an FIR as this might have legal implications. It is for the courts to decide if they will treat such complaints as FIRs or not.

Merely digitalizing complaints about lost cell phones is not progress in a country which sees over 33,000 murders, over 33,000 rapes, and over 77,000 kidnappings/abductions per year (2014 statistics reported in Violent Crimes – National Crime Records Bureau http://ncrb.nic.in/StatPublications/CII/CII2014/chapters/Chapter%203.pdf ).

If a victim or witness cannot complain promptly and in his/her own words about a crime, “Digital India” will only be a mirage! 

Visit https://jaagruti.org/2013/12/13/reporting-a-crime-all-about-lodging-an-f-i-r-with-the-police/ to read about the intricacies behind filing a complaint!

Pneumonia is in the News; where is preventive care?

Secretary Clinton’s pneumonia news had spread quickly around the world. http://www.nytimes.com/2016/09/12/us/politics/hillary-clinton-campaign-pneumonia.html?_r=0

A friend of ours in Bangalore was hospitalized by an attack of pneumonia and spent many days in the ICU. Both cases raised one question in my mind. Had the person been given a pneumonia vaccine injection earlier?  If not, why not?

This website run by CDC, a US Govt. agency, says that two-thirds of the adults in the US above 65 have taken pneumonia vaccine, but then one-third of the population in the US above 65 and not covered by the vaccine is over 15 million. http://www.cdc.gov/nchs/fastats/pneumonia.htm

It is not, therefore, surprising that “each year in the United States, about 1 million people have to seek care in a hospital due to pneumonia, and about 50,000 people die from the disease. Most of the people affected by pneumonia in the United States are adults”. Their hospital and school systems ensure that children are pretty well covered by vaccines.

We are a long way off in India from protecting our adult population from avoidable cases of pneumonia. The poor state of health care for the bulk of the population makes this very difficult. The number of deaths in India due to flu and pneumonia is over 500,000 per year. 

For a moment, let us look at people like the readers of this blog. Many of them probably undergo an annual medical test costing a few thousand rupees. This usually includes a consultation with a doctor. Have you heard a doctor in that situation ask you if you have ever taken a pneumonia vaccine? Or, a flu vaccine? Suppose you are overweight, but not obese, and do not have condition like diabetes or high blood pressure. (To be labelled obese, an adult has to be about 30 pounds over the prescribed weight). Do you think that the doctor would talk to you about your weight and encourage you to shed some of it?

Benjamin Franklin said “An ounce of prevention is worth a pound of cure”. Why don’t our doctors focus on preventive care?

I will conclude that in most cases of death by pneumonia below the age of 80, the cause of death should be identified as “lack of preventive health care”. I am not saying that pneumonia vaccine will give you a guarantee of surviving an attack of pneumonia. It is enough for me if it significantly increases the chances that you will avoid the attack.